How Different People Hear the Same Songs: a Collaboration With the Cheap seat Report

I said I had something different planned for Amanda Shires’ excellent new album besides the review. It’s an idea that came from my friend and fellow writer Michael Rauch, of The Cheap Seat Report. By the way, definitely check that blog out; Michael writes only about music he enjoys and from multiple genres, and he’s always got some interesting new music. Anyway, his idea was to look at how different people react to hearing the same song–he explains it better below–and he did a piece like this awhile back with another friend and writer that I absolutely loved. WE both really got into Amanda shires’ latest album, so it seemed natural to ask him to do this again. These are all real-time reactions as we listened to each of the songs on the album.

People listen to music differently. And that’s a good thing. Some people need meaningful lyrics, some need the instrumentation to be spot on. Some need familiar, some need interesting. I lean towards interesting and unexpected and good. Amanda Shires delivers on all of those.

“Parking Lot Pirouette”

I’m not one to interpret lyrics, that is for each individual listener, but these lyrics are great. It’s also a way to ease the listener into the fact that this is not going to be the Amanda Shires album that you were expecting.

What a way to open this album, atmospheric and soaring. And I love how she writes so poetically, painting the pictures of the constellations and stars. Really good way to capture the vibe of this whole record.

“Swimmer”

This song is totally 80s era Stevie Nicks. Which in my book, makes it awesome.

This is an older Shires song, but this version is better and fits better here with this production. Also nice track placement after “pirouette,” as both reflect images of desire.

“Leave It Alone”

Bubblegum pop for grownups. But if you go back and listen to a lot of bubblegum, it wasn’t just unicorns and rainbows either.

We’ve been hinting at desire, and all of it comes out in full force here. The effects on her vocals really add to this, making everything almost echo. I love the melody, the sound, the beautiful words, everything. This is my favorite.

“Charms”

This sounds so familiar and soothing. The sound belies the heaviness of the lyrics.

Nice, relaxed, more tender moment after the first three. Good to see a different side to Amanda Shires here as she sings about motherhood.

“Eve’s Daughter”

This is where the album takes off for me musically. This is where we point to when we say “Amanda Shires rocks”. It’s just a kickass rock song. If you had any doubts before, this is a rock album.

And now after the softest, most introspective moment comes the hardest-charging part of the album. This is just a jam. And the fragile shakes in her voice only add to this, as this whole thing sounds so ragged musically and determined lyrically, as if she’s desperate to get this story out of her.

“Break Out the Champagne”

90s alt rock to the core. Shires is showing her true colors in her love of rock on this track.

I love the attitude in this song, as she’s just saying we should embrace life and take the good with the bad, live each day like it’s our last. The plane lost an engine? Break out the champagne. Oh, if we could all be like that and just take life as it comes!

“Take on the Dark”

Southern Gothic Go-Go’s. Nothing more needs to be said.

This is another jam, and just like in “eve’s Daughter,” here, that quality in Shires’ vocals adds to the intensity. Another anthem about everything ultimately being all right, but what makes this one so different from all the others is that she admits life’s hard, saying, “it’s okay to fall apart” and “take on the dark, without letting it take over.”

“White Feather”

This is a great song. The keyboard, the bass, and guitar weave together perfectly. Shires’ vocals are perfect. Got some Tom Petty in there.

I don’t have much to say about this one, and these two here are my least favorites. I enjoy the poetic imagery of scarecrows and feathers, but this one hasn’t stuck musically with me.

“Mirror, Mirror”

This is a torch song. Could be performed on top of a grand piano, for effect.

This one hasn’t stuck with me as much either musically, and her vocals can be distracting here, but I do really like the message and the details, as Shires is singing about all the women that other women look up to and idolize which makes them feel worse about themselves.

“Wasn’t I Paying Attention”

This one reminds me of Dire Straits, the lilting instrumentation. Not Mark Knopfler, but the guitar solo is appropriate.

What a great way to close this out, hard rocking musically and so intense lyrically. It’s the tale of a man’s last morning on earth before he committed suicide, and it strikes me listening right now how catchy the song is in spite of it. I love that, that it’s a song about this subject without being so depressing in its execution.

Conclusion: It was interesting to read these reactions while listening to these songs, and this speaks to the unique and wonderful power of music, that two people can both appreciate an album so much and yet come up with such vastly different descriptions of it and reactions to it. This was a fun little exercise, but it’s also a case for the power of music itself to hit so many people in so many different ways. It’s also a testament to the value of others’ perspectives and opinions; in a world of division, music can bring us together in discussion. This particular discussion was a fun one, and what a great album to get to listen to while doing it.

Album Review: Jason Eady–I Travel On

Rating: 9/10

Jason Eady’s is a name I want to shout from rooftops and post on billboards, and if you ask me to name an underrated traditional artist getting criminally overlooked in 2018, I’ll say Eady every time. If Keith Whitley was his generation’s shot at Haggard and Jones, as Garth Brooks stated in his Country Music Hall of Fame induction, then Jason Eady is this generation’s shot at Keith Whitley, with a voice so pure and filled with emotion and absolutely born to sing traditional country music. There is a comfort in his voice and a talent in his pen rivaled by few, and this remains true album after album, as he continues to project great music out into the atmosphere without ever a lapse in quality. And yet the mainstream will never take notice, and even many independent fans won’t pay proper attention and give him the respect he is due, for Eady is not the country soul hybrid of Chris Stapleton or the rock/Americana blend of Jason Isbell, or even the upbeat Red dirt of Turnpike Troubadours. He’s too country for the success and recognition enjoyed by those artists, and it’s a shame because in a just world, Jason Eady would be a household name.

The pen of Jason Eady, as I mentioned, is his greatest strength. On any given day, you can pop in any of his previous three records and find something new and hidden in the lyrics. His turns of phrase are sneaky and riddled with deeper meaning, infused with subtlety and depth of emotion so that even months later, there’s something fresh to uncover. And yet, for all that, this new album isn’t really that way, the writing being more straightforward and direct. It’s not your typical Jason Eady record in that sense; the songwriting is more simple, though still great, and there’s not really a moment where you’re taken completely aback by the brilliance and poetry of a lyric like on some of his more recent material.

Yet I Travel On earns its place alongside all those other great Jason eady albums, and even above many of them–in fact, I would argue this is his best album aside from Daylight and Dark, which is my favorite record of all time–and it’s because of the sound and the instrumentation. seeing Eady live is a special experience and one that any fan of his or of live music in general should seek out. And now we get to hear this live touring band on an album, except made even better with the added harmonies of Courtney Patton that enhance every Jason Eady release. The whole thing was cut live in the studio, everything feeling loose and organic and vibrant. It’s all infectious and upbeat, the way you hear these songs out on the road. Bluegrass player Kevin Foster, who plays lead guitar and fiddle in Eady’s touring band, always adds so much to these songs live, and it’s great to hear that unleashed on a record. Not to mention the added bluegrass flair from Rob Ickes and Trey Hensley, two badass bluegrass pickers in their own right called upon to add flavor and vitality to this record.

And it was just the right time to add all these flourishes too, for as its title suggests, this album is very much a tale of the road, of restless characters passing through on their journeys. As I said, there isn’t one song or lyric that will blow you away, but the whole thing is injected with this rambling spirit that just works so well. We have songs like “That’s Alright” and the title track, where the narrators are trying to find themselves as they travel from place to place. In “She Had to Run,” our heroine is escaping abuse, leaving as fast as she possibly can because that’s the only thing left for her to do. And then there’s “The Climb,” where the man’s journey is metaphorical–he’s following a dream, and he’s reached the point on the mountain where he’s gone too far to turn back but can’t really reach the top. It’s just such a simple yet profound line when Eady sings, “he’s not lost, he just don’t know what to do.” I think we find ourselves in this position so often in our journey, at a crossroads and not knowing which way to turn.

It all comes to a head musically and lyrically in “Pretty When I Die,” where all these bluegrass hints and flourishes finally come bursting out, and all the energy and uncertainty of the road comes pouring out right along with it. In this little tune, Eady declares that he doesn’t want to take an easy route or travel on a road he’s already been on before, and that at the end of this whole journey of life, he wants to “look like a man who tried.” He wants a story for every line on his face when he dies. The introspective companion to this song, and the one that shows off the best instance of Jason’s writing on this project, is “Happy Man,” wherein he lets us know that if he dies today, he would die happy, and that he’s thankful for all of the blessings in his life.

Jason Eady has been blessed with the kind of comfort and healing in his voice that almost can’t be explained, a comfort which makes his stories ones that you have to listen to over and over. When he sings of traveling through life and the struggles and challenges that that entails, you just want to pull up a chair and listen, and draw from that wisdom. There is a thoughtfulness in his pen that is unmatched, and even if it doesn’t come out in overly deep lyrics like in some of his earlier output, it’s there in the beauty and simplicity of a song like “Always a Woman.” It’s that comfort and wisdom that draws you into any Jason Eady record, but I Travel On sets itself apart because it’s also infectious and catchy and able to be replayed for months, even after you’ve been captured that first time by the writing.

As an Eady fan, I do wish there had been a moment here that blew me away lyrically, and for longtime fans, there isn’t really a moment like that anywhere. But this album holds its own in his discography because it brings an energy and musicality that didn’t exist on any of Eady’s other records. Sometimes there’s something to be said for simplicity, for just singing three chords and the truth, and that’s what Jason Eady delivers with I Travel On. And this is the album to show people who don’t know his music, for this is the one that can bring people in and turn them on to the greatness we’ve all had the privilege of knowing. Now go and listen to this fine record.

Buy the Album

Album Review – Cliff Westfall – Baby You Win

Rating: 8/10

When I saw a review for Cliff Westfall’s Baby You Win on Saving Country Music, I knew I had to check this album out. In the review, the overall sound of this album was discussed, and I listened to one of the songs Trigger left for the readers to hear. It was fast, the sound was straight out of the 50s and 60s, and I was sold.

That song was the opening track, “It Hurt Her to Hurt Me”. With the faster tempo and overall production, I was immediately hooked. In my opinion, it’s got some of the best sounds of 50s and 60s country, but it’s not in a way that indicates copying or a gimmick. It’s simply Cliff Westfall’s style. The whole album just has this old-fashioned feel, and it’s brilliant. I love the varied tempos that are present here, too. Most, like “Hurt Her to Hurt Me”, are actually faster, and personally, I’m all for a faster album.

As varied as the tempos are, the overall theme of the album is love. Almost every song on the album discusses relationships, either the good or bad parts. The aforementioned “It Hurt Her to Hurt Me” is a song about a man whose partner has walked out on him after one too many instances of his wrongdoing. Still, he thinks it hurt her to hurt him. It’s hilarious, catchy, and a song I keep returning to. My favorite song off of this record is “The Man I Used to Be”. It’s a more upbeat song about the downfall of a relationship, all because the man isn’t meeting the higher standards he’d set for himself during the earlier days of their marriage. His wife isn’t looking for another man, she’s just wishing he was more like the man she married.

I won’t go into a track-by-track analysis about this album, simply because they really are mostly about the ups and downs of love. The only exception is “End of the Line”. It’s a fun song about someone who’s a bit too wild for his own good. I have to say,I do love how Cliff Westfall makes so many of these faster songs go more in-depth lyrically.

My least favorite has to be “Lie If You Must”. It just doesn’t really do anything for me. I could honestly do without this song. I just find it forgettable.

Still, this album is one you should check out if you’re into the 50s and 60s eras in country music. There’s sadness, happiness, and just some of the best production I’ve heard in a while. I love the instrumentation, too. This album cannot be classified as anything other than true traditional country. There’s something on this album for everyone, especially given the large focus on relationship-tnemed songs, and everyone knows that love is relatable. As this is Cliff Westfall’s debut album, I am excited to see what he does next.

Buy the Album on Amazon

Album Review – Cody Jinks – Lifers

Rating: 8/10

I’ve been a fan of Cody Jinks ever since I bought his last two albums. His style of country music, as well as his vocal delivery, really appeals to me. Therefore, when I heard that he was releasing a new album, and his first on Rounder Records, I was excited to hear it. Now that I have, I can safely say that he’s still making some of the best country music today.

The songs on this album have various themes. The track I like the most, though, is the cover of “Stranger”. It’s all about how he doesn’t recognize the man in the mirror. He’s getting older, but it doesn’t fit with the way he sees himself. I just really like this kind of reflective song. My second favorite is the title track, “Lifers”. It’s all about the struggles of the working man. No matter how hard things get, he keeps on going. It reminds me of people I know who do the same, and i think this kind of song is something we should hear more often.

“Colorado” is a slower love song that I liked upon first hearing it. The melody is one that’s stuck in my head, and in the song, he’s saying that he hopes the woman he used to be with doesn’t believe that he never thinks about her or Colorado, because that’s simply not true. I also really enjoyed the fun and upbeat “Big Last Name”, which is all about a woman marrying someone with a big last name and lots of money just to keep the privileges she’s grown up with all of her life. “Must Be the Whiskey” is a song I like for its melody as well as the catchy chorus. The man in the song is tormented by a past love, and he’s trying to remember and drinking to forget. “Desert Wind” is interesting both lyrically and instrumentally. The tempo is somewhere in the middle, and the melody is darker. It’s the story of a man on a journey to Mexico, who ultimately didn’t find what he was searching for and came back home. It stood out to me because of its uniqueness.

The rest of the songs are likable, not bad, though not ones that stood out quite as much. My least favorite is probably “Head Case”, just because it hasn’t really stuck with me at all. I also find “Holy Water”, the opening track, a bit forgettable, though the song’s instrumentation is definitely fun.

The thing I really appreciate about this album is that all of the songs aren’t the same thematically. There’s songs about life’s struggles, leaving a relationship, remembering past love, and even one about making an unfortunate trip to Mexico. Along with that, I love how the tempos and instrumentation are varied. I can definitely say that you never get bored while listening to this album. The steel guitar is awesome, and there was even some piano, which I think is a very under-used instrument in country music. This is definitely one of the liveliest albums I’ve heard this year, in terms of musicianship.

Overall, Lifers is another solid addition to the discography of Cody Jinks. It’s fun, thought-provoking, and full of country instrumentation. While it doesn’t reach the great heights of Adobe Sessions or I’m Not the Devil, that’s okay. It doesn’t have to. As long as Cody Jinks keeps making consistent country music like this, I’ll keep on listening.

Buy the Album on Amazon

Album Review: Amanda Shires–To the Sunset

Rating: 9/10

Wow, what a fascinating and captivating album! From the opening notes of “Parking Lot Pirouette,” with its spacey, atmospheric production and poetic lyrics about the constellations and Aquarius, I knew this was something different and special. I have worn out this album in the past week since it became an NPR First Listen, especially in the past two days since it became available to buy, and it’s one of those records where not only could I not wait to write about it, but I also had to force myself to sit down and write about it rather than continue to listen to it over and over instead. It’s one of those albums that is exactly the reason I do this, the reason that any of us do, because when music hits you like this, you just want to share it, and thank God for this outlet where I get to do that with you all. For the record, I haven’t been an Amanda shires apologist previously, and also for the record, this isn’t like any other album she’s yet given us. It’s not country or even Americana; this is a rock album, despite its apple Music label of “singer-songwriter.” But damn, is it a good rock album, and it reminds you just how much rock and country are similar in that both are beloved genres of American music marginalized and endangered in 2018.

I mentioned that opener, “Parking Lot Pirouette,” and it may be one of the best opening tracks of the year in terms of hooking me on an album and establishing the mood of the record. desire and sensuality run heavily through the songs of To the Sunset, especially in these first three. In this opening song, the narrator is seducing her lover in a parking lot, turning around and telling him, in response to his comment that she won’t get far, “you’re right, I’m not done with you yet.” “Swimmer,” recorded on a previous Shires album in a more country fashion, deals with the daydreams of a past love, but the echoes of desire are here too, as she sings of wishing he’d “come hover over me and speak something close to me.” And then there’s “Leave it Alone,” a highlight on a stellar album, where the vocal effects work to perfection as Amanda sings of finding new places on her lover’s body, and the desire that she can’t, well, leave alone. Shires’ MFA in poetry is on full display here; it is on much of this album, but it’s especially impressive and beautiful here because there are only so many ways you can write about sex, and she does so both elegantly and sensually.

And Dave Cobb deserves a world of credit for this effort in production; this almost seems outside the confines of his Dave Cobb ways, and yet in terms of making Amanda shires and her songs come alive in the best way possible, he absolutely excels here. This may be his best production I’ve ever heard as far as bringing out the best in an artist. The distortion works excellently on the hardest rocking track here, an instantly re-playable number called “Eve’s daughter.” The shakes and tremors in Amanda’s voice would come off as frail on certain songs, or if left too bare by the arrangements, but they work instead to enhance songs like “Break out the Champagne” and the aforementioned “Parking Lot Pirouette.” It is a great case of taking one’s vocal tone and using it as an advantage; I know Amanda Shires has been self-conscious of this vocal characteristic in the past, but it only serves to add character to these songs, and that’s both a credit to her finding the right style for her voice and to Cobb’s dedication to her vision.

I could go into more detail about these songs, but I’d be here until this time tomorrow night and miss my flight tomorrow morning. Also, I have something else planned, and I don’t want to defeat the purpose of that. But I can’t say enough about this record. If you are at all into rock music, particularly 80’s rock, or if you are at all into poetic, thoughtful songwriting, please check this out. What a masterpiece, and something truly unique and fresh. Yes, this album will definitely be there in the conversation when those December lists come around. Amanda shires should be extremely proud of this.

Buy the Album

The Most Destructive Criticism is Indifference